Welcome to Mama Carolla's
In the heart of Indianapolis lies Mama Carolla's, a charming Italian restaurant that not only caters to vegan and vegetarian diets but also offers a romantic setting for a memorable dining experience. With a full bar, outdoor seating, and wheelchair accessibility, Mama Carolla's ensures that all guests feel welcome. The restaurant's commitment to providing excellent service and delicious cuisine makes it a standout in the culinary scene. From the cozy ambiance to the delectable dishes, Mama Carolla's truly embodies the essence of Italian dining in every aspect.
- 1031 E 54th St Indianapolis, IN 46220 Hotline: (317) 259-9412
If you're in the mood for authentic and delightful Italian cuisine in Indianapolis, look no further than Mama Carolla's. Located at 1031 E. 54th St, this charming restaurant offers a range of amenities such as takeout, delivery, vegan options, and even cryptocurrency payments. You can enjoy your meal in their romantic outdoor seating area or inside their cozy dining room, all while being served by their friendly staff. Mama Carolla's is not just a place to eat, it's an experience that you won't soon forget. From the moment you walk in, you can feel the love and passion that goes into every dish, making it a must-visit spot for any food lover. So grab your loved ones, make a reservation, and treat yourself to a taste of Italy at Mama Carolla's.

The food was great, and the service was decent. Our waiter disappeared at one point for a while when we were ready to leave. Had to wait a bit, but that was it. The atmosphere was nice.

Great experience here. The food was delicious and decent portions sizes for the price. Our server was attentive and checked on us throughout our meal. The decor is starting to feel a bit dated at this point and could be modernized while still keeping the home style appeal. Easy recommendation for great Italian meal in Indy!

The atmosphere of this place is amazing. It is a very cozy/romantic setting. The service was excellent and very personable which made the experience even more enjoyable. The menu features a wide variety of items so everyone should be able to find something they like. The food quality was excellent. The salad and bread were great as well. To top it all off the prices aren't overly expensive. We'll definitely be back!

Another fantastic example of a place exceeding expectations on your views from years prior, despite then being incredibly lofty. Great service and classic Italian fare done correctly. The Misto Mare had the perfect cook on the seafood and was served over perfect al dente pasta. One of the best patios as well and excited to be able to frequent here again!

Without a doubt, hands down, the BEST meal we’ve ever had in our entire lives. Our server was an absolute delight and that’s not even to mention the ambience of the establishment. We ordered, well to be frank, everything!???? Fried Ravioli, bruschetta, chicken parm, shrimp Alfredo, tiramisu, wine, Moscow mule, and it was all beyond fantastic. If you’re in Indy even for just one night make this your dinner stop!

The atmosphere made this experience something worth talking about! The service was good, but not the best I've had. I waited with an empty glass of water for about 10 minutes before it was filled, but the food was very memorable and I'd recommend for sure. I had the veal parm with a side of sausage.

Classic Italian menu, but had the special of the evening Cajun Chicken, andouie sausage with a spicy cream sauce. Very good. The wine list has more then normal number of wines by the glass. There were four of us so we tried 2 of their appetizers. The artichoke fritters, and the crab stuffed portobello mushroom. Both delicious. Sat inside because it was hot but their outside seating is lovely as is the bar.

This is a hidden gem. I didn't know it was there until recently since it's not in our neighborhood. Our waitress, Ashley, was fantastic and super attentive even though she was doing the stairs the whole time. We started with the bruschetta and it was phenomenal. A couple of us had the chicken rigatoni which was fabulous with the Rizzo style. The traditional lasagna has a unique marinara that was very tasty. I had the pasta too good Rizzo style and it was delicious. Then we tried the tiramisu and the creme brulee for dessert and they were both great. We were so excited to eat that we forgot pics until the leftovers were boxed. Highly recommend you visit.

We came here for one of our first dates back in 2009, returned for several other special occasions over the years. We no longer live in Indianapolis but were in town for the mini marathon this weekend and went back. The food was amazing. The server was great and it was perfect weather to sit outside.

The food is amazing every time I go. There can be a wait to be seated if you go on the weekend but this is my favorite date night dinner place to go! The service can also be kind of slow because it’s always so packed. Overall the food, atmosphere, and overall experience is definitely worth it if you want a sweet relaxing date night!